(Bare in mind, huge thread.)
There are a few fond memories I remember back from my early days on the ZU forums, around '08 or so. Besides once being an avid theorist back when the theorizing board was a little more active and had a community of sorts within it (I kind of miss that too), I was also a hard working editor over at the Zelda Wiki. Back then, I would even say that there were more people on the forums who also worked on the wiki.
Now when I look at things, frankly, I see a lack of attention and even what I might call negligence between ZU and the wiki.
Back in '08-9, I used to closely work with this group of people who all contributed a lot to the wiki. We had our own social group on the forums, which is still around but no longer used, and we also used to use Skype to discuss plans and such. We were all very hard workers then, and I think our efforts were actually a little more appreciated back then, or at least how I remember it. And I loved every last bit of it. When I was doing that, I actually felt like I was part of something with the forums, like there was this appreciated community within it that was doing some good for a wiki a lot of people used. But sadly things tend to change, the people whom I all worked with and became friends with are all since gone and having moved on. I actually still really miss those guys. And other sites that used to be affiliated with the wiki just kind of broke off. It's sad. I actually miss a lot of things here on ZU.
But the thing I miss most of all? I miss there being a wiki community of sorts. I miss seeing quality work go into the wiki and being kept up-to-date. I miss how ZU doesn't seem to care for the Zelda Wiki as much as it once used to, or at least that's how it now looks like to my eyes. It's almost funny. Zelda Wiki has been and is supposed to be a close affiliate of ZU, and to my knowledge they're even owned by the same site owner. ZU is even listed in Zelda Wiki's Community Partners and its news postings are even shared on the wiki's front page. There is also the ZW Contributor banner that is exclusive to these forums, as well as a member group on these forums for wiki staff. People here still also use the ZW as their main source of Zelda info, especially in the theorizing board. Despite this, there is no sense of dedication or even attention to the wiki on the forums or site. I see a couple people in said member group who are now inactive or absent. The website doesn't even link to the wiki anymore ever since it was revamped. That was one of the first things I noticed, and it actually really bothered me. It all honestly feels kind of dead.
It has been nothing short of frustrating and disappointing for me, as well as saddening. I've had a couple of users come to me because they see my contributor banner and ask me things like who's in charge now or how they can get their own banner, and it frustrates me when I have to tell them that I don't know or that I can't help them.
For a wiki that has had a lot of work poured into it, it saddens me that it's not featured more. If you were to look at the Goron article, a quarter of what you would see there was my own work, and I helped to make the article a featured article back when the wiki was still doing those. One major contributor was even the one who brought up the idea of NIWA - the Nintendo Independent Wiki Alliance, and thanks to his efforts ZW is affiliated with many other well known and respected Nintendo wikis like Bulbapedia, Super Mario Wiki, and so on. Unfortunately with the decline of things, I even kind of lost my motivation to contribute there anymore, and I actually feel guilty because of that.
Basically, I want change. I want to see more effort and dedication be put in place in the relation between ZU and ZW. I want to see the wiki more accessible to people, I want there to be more awareness for the wiki, and I want ZU's relation with it to be expanded and improved. I am tired of being quiet and frustrated about this for the past three years that I noticed this decline. And I have a couple of big suggestions to make.
Make a sub-forum dedicated for the Zelda Wiki project
And why not? I think this would be a perfect step in getting people more involved with the wiki and projects into place. I know that the Bulbagarden forums made a board for their own wiki, and it worked pretty well from what I can see as a member there. A wiki sub-forum could be used for the discussion of wiki ideas and proposed projects. It can be used to make announcements, to bring up things for the wiki staff to be more aware of. It can allow for more extensive discussion without having to take things into Talk Pages and clutter them up. It can serve as an introduction for new people who also want to contribute to the wiki. It can help it grow and prosper. And given ZW's relation to ZU, I really think a sub-forum would be beneficial for both.
If section mods are a problem, then just closely work with the ZW staff and make them be section mods. You'd have to be working closely with them anyway, obviously it would be better if the board is monitored by the same people staffed in the wiki. Or just find new people who are also dedicated to the wiki.
On a whole, I believe a sub-forum would make a lot of things between ZW and ZU easier. Ideas, suggestions and projects can be exchanged, members can feel more helpful, and there would be a place to keep all of these things in. I implore that this be seriously considered.
And another thing,
Reduce the edit requirements for the ZW Contributor banner
The ZW Contributor banner is awarded to persons who have made an active contribution to the wiki, it shows their efforts and appreciation for all their hard work, and to me it's also been about incentive for people to contribute to the wiki. I don't really know what happened, but the new requirements for the banner is to make 1000 edits. To me that's too much, and I cannot remember there ever being such a high requirement for the banner before. I don't remember ever having to make that many edits to get my banner, and my userpage states that I have only ever made 600+ edits. When was this changed?
Personally, 1000 edits just sounds way too much. Unless you're making an effort on editing every day, you wouldn't get that far very quickly. It shouldn't be this high of a number, especially when the intention is to give incentive and to award people for their appreciated hard work. 1000 is a lot for wiki editing, and if I saw that, I'd be turned off from attempting to reach that. I suggest that it be lowered down to 200-300, or even just 500. That way people would still have to work hard without having to spam the wiki just to get a banner, but would feel much more motivated to reach it. Motivation is a key in contribution.
But ultimately, what I just want to see most is attention, dedication, and appreciation again. A rework of things. Not for the wiki to be such a tiny project, it deserves to be bigger and to be embraced. It is owned by the same person who also owns ZU, right? I know a lot of people here go to ZU for the community boards than anything Zelda and I know that the wiki has been caught in the middle of website drama before in the past. But I just want to see the wiki grow again. Me and others worked very hard on it, it deserves more.
There are a few fond memories I remember back from my early days on the ZU forums, around '08 or so. Besides once being an avid theorist back when the theorizing board was a little more active and had a community of sorts within it (I kind of miss that too), I was also a hard working editor over at the Zelda Wiki. Back then, I would even say that there were more people on the forums who also worked on the wiki.
Now when I look at things, frankly, I see a lack of attention and even what I might call negligence between ZU and the wiki.
Back in '08-9, I used to closely work with this group of people who all contributed a lot to the wiki. We had our own social group on the forums, which is still around but no longer used, and we also used to use Skype to discuss plans and such. We were all very hard workers then, and I think our efforts were actually a little more appreciated back then, or at least how I remember it. And I loved every last bit of it. When I was doing that, I actually felt like I was part of something with the forums, like there was this appreciated community within it that was doing some good for a wiki a lot of people used. But sadly things tend to change, the people whom I all worked with and became friends with are all since gone and having moved on. I actually still really miss those guys. And other sites that used to be affiliated with the wiki just kind of broke off. It's sad. I actually miss a lot of things here on ZU.
But the thing I miss most of all? I miss there being a wiki community of sorts. I miss seeing quality work go into the wiki and being kept up-to-date. I miss how ZU doesn't seem to care for the Zelda Wiki as much as it once used to, or at least that's how it now looks like to my eyes. It's almost funny. Zelda Wiki has been and is supposed to be a close affiliate of ZU, and to my knowledge they're even owned by the same site owner. ZU is even listed in Zelda Wiki's Community Partners and its news postings are even shared on the wiki's front page. There is also the ZW Contributor banner that is exclusive to these forums, as well as a member group on these forums for wiki staff. People here still also use the ZW as their main source of Zelda info, especially in the theorizing board. Despite this, there is no sense of dedication or even attention to the wiki on the forums or site. I see a couple people in said member group who are now inactive or absent. The website doesn't even link to the wiki anymore ever since it was revamped. That was one of the first things I noticed, and it actually really bothered me. It all honestly feels kind of dead.
It has been nothing short of frustrating and disappointing for me, as well as saddening. I've had a couple of users come to me because they see my contributor banner and ask me things like who's in charge now or how they can get their own banner, and it frustrates me when I have to tell them that I don't know or that I can't help them.
For a wiki that has had a lot of work poured into it, it saddens me that it's not featured more. If you were to look at the Goron article, a quarter of what you would see there was my own work, and I helped to make the article a featured article back when the wiki was still doing those. One major contributor was even the one who brought up the idea of NIWA - the Nintendo Independent Wiki Alliance, and thanks to his efforts ZW is affiliated with many other well known and respected Nintendo wikis like Bulbapedia, Super Mario Wiki, and so on. Unfortunately with the decline of things, I even kind of lost my motivation to contribute there anymore, and I actually feel guilty because of that.
Basically, I want change. I want to see more effort and dedication be put in place in the relation between ZU and ZW. I want to see the wiki more accessible to people, I want there to be more awareness for the wiki, and I want ZU's relation with it to be expanded and improved. I am tired of being quiet and frustrated about this for the past three years that I noticed this decline. And I have a couple of big suggestions to make.
Make a sub-forum dedicated for the Zelda Wiki project
And why not? I think this would be a perfect step in getting people more involved with the wiki and projects into place. I know that the Bulbagarden forums made a board for their own wiki, and it worked pretty well from what I can see as a member there. A wiki sub-forum could be used for the discussion of wiki ideas and proposed projects. It can be used to make announcements, to bring up things for the wiki staff to be more aware of. It can allow for more extensive discussion without having to take things into Talk Pages and clutter them up. It can serve as an introduction for new people who also want to contribute to the wiki. It can help it grow and prosper. And given ZW's relation to ZU, I really think a sub-forum would be beneficial for both.
If section mods are a problem, then just closely work with the ZW staff and make them be section mods. You'd have to be working closely with them anyway, obviously it would be better if the board is monitored by the same people staffed in the wiki. Or just find new people who are also dedicated to the wiki.
On a whole, I believe a sub-forum would make a lot of things between ZW and ZU easier. Ideas, suggestions and projects can be exchanged, members can feel more helpful, and there would be a place to keep all of these things in. I implore that this be seriously considered.
And another thing,
Reduce the edit requirements for the ZW Contributor banner
The ZW Contributor banner is awarded to persons who have made an active contribution to the wiki, it shows their efforts and appreciation for all their hard work, and to me it's also been about incentive for people to contribute to the wiki. I don't really know what happened, but the new requirements for the banner is to make 1000 edits. To me that's too much, and I cannot remember there ever being such a high requirement for the banner before. I don't remember ever having to make that many edits to get my banner, and my userpage states that I have only ever made 600+ edits. When was this changed?
Personally, 1000 edits just sounds way too much. Unless you're making an effort on editing every day, you wouldn't get that far very quickly. It shouldn't be this high of a number, especially when the intention is to give incentive and to award people for their appreciated hard work. 1000 is a lot for wiki editing, and if I saw that, I'd be turned off from attempting to reach that. I suggest that it be lowered down to 200-300, or even just 500. That way people would still have to work hard without having to spam the wiki just to get a banner, but would feel much more motivated to reach it. Motivation is a key in contribution.
But ultimately, what I just want to see most is attention, dedication, and appreciation again. A rework of things. Not for the wiki to be such a tiny project, it deserves to be bigger and to be embraced. It is owned by the same person who also owns ZU, right? I know a lot of people here go to ZU for the community boards than anything Zelda and I know that the wiki has been caught in the middle of website drama before in the past. But I just want to see the wiki grow again. Me and others worked very hard on it, it deserves more.